A finished product tells me what you made. Your design journal should help me understand how you arrived there.
Why did you choose that arrangement? What did you find out? What changed because of it?
If those connections are missing, a page full of sketches and photographs can still leave your thinking invisible.
Record the decision while it is happening
In my earlier writing, I described the design journal as a record of your thinking process. A question in your head can become a written question. An emerging idea can become a quick sketch. An observation can become a note beside the feature it concerns.
You do not need to wait until you have a confident answer.
Suppose you are uncertain whether someone can reach into a proposed holder. Record that uncertainty, try a suitable model, and note what you discover. The investigation and its consequence belong together.
A short record made at the time is often more useful than a polished explanation written weeks later, when you can no longer remember why you changed something.
Connect evidence to a change
Consider my clipboard pen-holder project.
I began with a sketch of the pen’s cross-section and a grip around it. The first printed version held the pen during light handling, but a nudge on the unsupported section could dislodge it. I subsequently doubled the gripping section’s length and added slots to the mounting plate.
Those are different kinds of information: an initial proposal, an observation, and a subsequent change.
A journal should make their relationship clear. A photograph of the longer grip shows what changed. By itself, it does not explain the problem that prompted the change—or establish that the revised version solved it.
That needs an accompanying explanation and further checking.
“Improved the design” tells the reader very little. Explain which feature changed, what evidence informed that decision, and what remains unresolved.
The same principle applies throughout Needs Analysis, Idea Conceptualisation, Development and Prototyping. Research matters when you can explain what you learned and how it affected your next move. Sometimes the finding supports keeping an existing decision. Sometimes it reveals another question.
Make the connections easy to follow
One recurring problem in my students’ journals has been the presence of useful work whose purpose is difficult to identify.
A page may show several variations without explaining what is being varied. Research may appear without any indication of how it influenced the design. A detailed drawing may arrive with no visible connection to earlier investigations.
Use a heading that identifies the question: “Checking access to the stored pens” is more informative than “Development”.
Place observations beside the relevant photograph or sketch. Point to the feature being discussed. Refer back to the requirement or user need that informed your judgement.
When a decision depends on information elsewhere, direct the reader to it. They should not have to search through the whole journal and guess which measurement or observation you used.
Also identify where information and help came from. Distinguish your own investigation from a reference image, a teacher’s demonstration or another person’s suggestion. Explain what you understood and decided as a result.
Improve the explanation without inventing the journey
You can revisit your journal to improve its clarity. Add a missing label, clarify a conclusion, or explain an observation more precisely.
But do not invent earlier alternatives or tests to make the process appear complete.
If you discover an unresolved issue late in the project, investigate it now and record it as a new investigation. If you add an explanation later, make its timing clear. Keep the original evidence where it helps establish what actually happened.
A genuine change of mind is useful evidence. So is a test that exposes a limitation. Neither needs to be disguised as a smooth progression towards an answer you supposedly knew all along.
My Independence Test offers a useful way to review your work: can another person understand it without relying on you to fill the gaps? For a design journal, ask whether they can follow the important decisions and their reasons.
Before moving on, check one significant decision. Can you point to the evidence that informed it, explain what you decided, and show what happened next?
#DesignJournal #DesignDocumentation #DesignDecisions #DesignProcess #DesignAndTechnology #DesignJournalSOS
Previous: Sketches, Models and Annotations · Series contents
Like my contents? Support me, support my work? Buy me a Coffee?
































